Journal of Management Information Systems

Volume 39 Number 4 2022 pp. 1184-1214

Approaching IT Security & Avoiding Threats in the Smart Home Context

Nehme, Alaa and George, Joey F

ABSTRACT:

Not securing smart home devices has proven a threat to cyberspace. This has underscored the importance of using fear appeals to promote users’ information security behavior. We practiced context-specific theorization to enhance fear appeal theory and design. Particularly, we extended Protection Motivation Theory to include avoidant-focused motivation (i.e., users’ intent to avoid using their devices), the positive emotion of hope, and information technology (IT)-self extension. Our hypotheses include that fear engenders both protection and avoidant-focused motivations, hope mediates coping appraisal to engender (reduce) protection (avoidant-focused) motivation, and IT-self-extension acts as an antecedent. We conducted four studies, including two surveys and two experiments, and validated our extensions. Our main theoretical contributions include showing that hope is critical in determining which coping mechanism occurs and that it improves the theory’s predictive power. In terms of practice, we demonstrate that a fear appeal message with a self-extension component and a strong coping component is more effective.

Key words and phrases: Information security, fear appeals, extended protection motivation theory, self-extension, smart home, home security